Ordered Triumph

"Ordered Triumph" is a surprising spin on the classic Triumph plot.

The deck is shuffled face up into face down. They then pick a card and lose it back in the deck, which is shuffled again. The cards are clearly a mess of face-up and face-down cards.

With a wave of your hands, you then make all the cards face the same direction again. Except for one card, their card. As an added kicker, the entire deck is also now in new deck order.

"Order Triumph" is a clean and direct effect that doesn't require any difficult sleight of hand. Since it's designed to match most USPCC playing cards, you can use favorite back design.